What's new

CCHR U.K.: "Drugs to Curb Children Cause Concern" 1/31/07

Tigger

Patron Meritorious
Geesh, no mention at all who the CCHR and what their agenda really are.

It's letter to the editor writing time!

Tigger

Drugs To Curb Childrens Behaviour Cause Concern (from Worcester News)
http://www.worcesternews.co.uk/most...to_curb_childrens_behaviour_cause_concern.php

Drugs to curb children's behaviour cause concern

QUESTIONS have been raised over the number of children in Worcestershire being prescribed psychiatric drugs for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD).

Figures obtained by the Citizens Commission On Human Rights (CCHR), a psychiatric watchdog group, reveal that 7,760 prescriptions for ADHD drugs were given out across the county in 2005/06 at a cost of £364,000.

But the group says ADHD is a controversial psychiatric condition that's never been scientifically proven' and dubs the drugs, commonly known as the chemical cosh', as like a mental health Asbo' to curb poor behaviour.

It also points to drug alerts from regulatory agencies detailing the serious side effects of ADHD drugs which can include visual hallucinations, suicidal thoughts, psychotic behaviour, violence and aggression.

Brian Daniels, national spokesman for CCHR in the UK, said: "Psychiatric propaganda has thoroughly duped well-meaning parents, teachers and politicians alike that normal childhood behaviour is no longer normal - that it's a mental illness.

"Children end up believing they have something wrong with their brains that makes it impossible to control themselves without using a pill.

"While it cannot be denied that some children have problems learning in school, that some can be excessively active, argumentative and even disruptive, psychiatry's fixation on labelling such difficulties as a mental illness, or disorder is not only unscientific, but medical fraud."

But Dr Richard Harling, consultant in public health at Worcestershire Primary Care Trust, said ADHD can have serious consequences for children, their families and carers.

He added: "It may lead to low self-esteem, emotional and social problems, and under-achievement at school. If it continues into adolescence and adulthood, it can cause ongoing social problems and may lead to drug misuse, unemployment and involvement in crime.

"A group of medicines known as central nervous system stimulants have been shown to be effective treatments for ADHD. The National Institute For Health And Clinical Excellence (NICE) recommend that if a child or adolescent needs treatment with medication for ADHD then these medicines should all be considered as possible choices.

"Treatment should only be started after a specialist who is an expert in ADHD has thoroughly assessed the child or adolescent and confirmed the diagnosis.

"Once treatment has been started it can be continued and monitored by a GP.

"Clinicians in Worcestershire work to the NICE recommendations to ensure that all children and adolescents get the care that they need."

11:03am Wednesday 31st January 2007

By Rebecca Bourne
 

neuf08

New Member
Thanks...that's quite an interesting article. As a former teacher, I definitely believe that ADD/ADHD is valid and legitimate, although I would also agree it's probably a bit over-diagnosed. I do also that some could avoid medicating with a change in diet, and the addition of the appropriate supplements. There are not some good child ADD treatments that combine a blend of supplements to help children remain calm and increase their focus. There have also been many who report very good things about using a children's DHA. The omegas really work with the brain to help focus and attention.
 

Iknowtoomuch

Gold Meritorious Patron
Welcome to ESMB Neuf08.

I agree that we jump to drugs far too much too often but to lump all children into one bag as not needing any drugs like CCHR thinks is just insane.
 

nexus100

Gold Meritorious Patron
On this one I'll differ. "Needing" drugs means you haven't found out what is wrong. No generation has spent the massive amount of time in front of TV's, computers and videos that this one has. Food preservatives, sugar and fast food are relatively new as well. Both parents work and there are often split families so kids get less attention, less love and less communication in the home. And big drug is huge and very influential. Kids were NEVER drugged when I was attending school and things went fine. What changed wasn't the kids.
 

Zinjifar

Silver Meritorious Sponsor
I think you've got way to many generalities on both the generations and the drugging here to mean much.

I'm a member of the first 'TV Generation' and also one of the first 'doper generations', despite the fact that I came from a family that rejected *any* 'additives' up to and including chewing gum :)

I did get ritalin prescribed when I was 19 or so, for about 2 weeks, until my girlfriend at the time objected that it made me really irritating. In retrospect, I can see it :)

Still, it might have addressed a chronic depressive system which has and does remain with me, although, I've found other measures to address it, including, most successfully, recognizing that it exists and discounting it as a basis for life decisions.

And, it's fun too :) Ritalin and LSD is one really weird crepe paper blizzard combination. On the other hand, I don't recommend mixing it with alky, since it allows coherent behavior far beyond the borders of the bizarre usually precluded by black out.

Do I think pschoactive drugs are overprescribed out of laziness? Certainly. Do I think they're in general not a 'good thing'?

No. Far more certainly. I know people who can function *because* they can medicate what are obviously physical problems. I know for a fact that mental states like depression, OCD etc. tie very neatly into the very human nature to 'habit' and, that it's a huge therapeutic success to break that habit building before it becomes overwhelming.

Are drugs good? I don't know. Sometimes they're good. Sometimes they're useful. Sometimes they're necessary.

Sometimes they're just fun, but, that's not what we're talking about here.

Zinj
 

nexus100

Gold Meritorious Patron
I think you've got way to many generalities on both the generations and the drugging here to mean much.

I'm a member of the first 'TV Generation' and also one of the first 'doper generations', despite the fact that I came from a family that rejected *any* 'additives' up to and including chewing gum :)

I did get ritalin prescribed when I was 19 or so, for about 2 weeks, until my girlfriend at the time objected that it made me really irritating. In retrospect, I can see it :)

Still, it might have addressed a chronic depressive system which has and does remain with me, although, I've found other measures to address it, including, most successfully, recognizing that it exists and discounting it as a basis for life decisions.

And, it's fun too :) Ritalin and LSD is one really weird crepe paper blizzard combination. On the other hand, I don't recommend mixing it with alky, since it allows coherent behavior far beyond the borders of the bizarre usually precluded by black out.

Do I think pschoactive drugs are overprescribed out of laziness? Certainly. Do I think they're in general not a 'good thing'?

No. Far more certainly. I know people who can function *because* they can medicate what are obviously physical problems. I know for a fact that mental states like depression, OCD etc. tie very neatly into the very human nature to 'habit' and, that it's a huge therapeutic success to break that habit building before it becomes overwhelming.

Are drugs good? I don't know. Sometimes they're good. Sometimes they're useful. Sometimes they're necessary.

Sometimes they're just fun, but, that's not what we're talking about here.

Zinj

As I see it your post largely supports my position.

I'm not talking about people with crippling physical problems. I don't take the COS viewpoint that you can't take an aspirin for a headache. What I am talking about is the use of Ritalin and other "brain" drugs to fix "mental" problems. Especially in kids, where behavoir problems likely either aren't problems at all or have their source in diet, lifestyle and a lack of love and attention at home.

There are MILLIONS of kids on these drugs. We are risking crippling a generation to make money for drug companies.

I can say with confidence drugging people to "fix" their mental state is not the best solution nearly 100% of the time.
 

Royal Prince Xenu

Trust the Psi Corps.
There is a cure for "ADD/ADHD

In Japan fluoridated water has been banned.

Vaccinations of children under the age of two has also been banned--because the preservative used in these vaccines in mercury based.

The results have been amazing--a cwey significant drop in ADD/ADHD cases and SIDS is almost non-existent.
 
Top