Re: Bali
Or, looking at this question from slightly different angles, several questions could be raised...
... is it better to be retired on a fixed-income pension in a country/ economy where your little pension barely covers your basic needs? or in a country/ economy where (by comparison to the income of the local inhabitants) your little pension buys you a life of wealth and privilege?
... is it better to be one of the unemployed poor (or "retired") in a rich country? or in a poor country?
... is it better to be one of the working poor in a rich country? or in a poor country?
I think the rich really can't be bothered with such questions, one way or another ... that is, until they are by some twist of fate forced to join the poor as in your example of the person who fell from the riches of a $2.5 home to the discomfort of the $500 room ... oops.
How very distressing to be forced to get along on a pittance equivalent to what one once paid to one's servants...
Replying to your post above, but not in order.
First, where I live, Silicon Valley, CA, no one would consider a $2.5 M house wealthy with servants. It is upper middle class. They probably had someone cleaning the house once a week.
As a basis of comparison, the house next door to us is for sale for $1.7M. It is approx 600 square feet on about 1/4 acre of land. It has a county sewer with a ten foot easement running through the length of the lot. It is fairly priced.
My point was and is that the SAME AMOUNT OF DOLLARS buys wildly different amounts of housing , food, and service.
I know homeless guys, who get $45.00 an hour for handyman work.
I have friends (this word not used loosely), who are illegal aliens, AKA "wetbacks", who own their own homes, and are paid for the quality of their work, very fairly. In the job pool, here, people are judged by the quality and speed of their work. They have done plenty of work for me, and were paid nothing even comparable to minimum wage.
I grew up on farms. At an early age, I got a healthy dose of respect for immigrants, usually illegal, and their work ethic.
I think it is a false viewpoint to ask:
"... is it better to be one of the
unemployed poor (or "retired") in a rich country? or in a poor country?
... is it better to be one of the
working poor in a rich country? or in a poor country?"
from my viewpoint, the question(s) should be what quality of work, of challenge, of "following your dream" are you pursuing? Where can that best be done?
Our youngest daughter, who grew up in Silicon Valley and La La Land, with her own horse from the time she was a baby,
was a member of SAG and AFTRA since she was 4, on a successful TV series (still played in reruns) got an MA from Stanford, a local university, has lived in Beijing, Shanghai, West Africa,
and currently lives and works in Haiti. * see footnote
She is making a difference in the poorest country in the western hemisphere.
More important than her pay, is the difference she makes on people, who need help. That isn't something money can quantify.
Compared to one of her brothers, who is a high school graduate (barely), she makes bupkis. Compared to her sister, a high school equivalency test completion, she really makes spare change.
The name of the game, as I see it, is to really fill your niche in life, to play hard to contribute your best, at what you are good at, and want to be doing. The money should never be the focus.
Obviously, we all need enough to eat and sleep in some comfort and safety, but again, those are relative values.
The other point being, not to be a parasite on the hard work of others. There are plenty of people, both rich and poor, who fall into this category. Tom Cruise's friend, Davey, falls into this one big time, as did his mentor, the atomic physicist and best friend of mankind.
* footnote:
DOMINICAN REPUBLIC DAILY SUMMARY
MAY, 29
POSITIVE 6 NEGATIVE 1 NEUTRAL 0
Nacion Dominicana
Martelly-Lamothe announces "Ti Manman Cheri" Program for vulnerable families
The Prime Minister, Mr. Laurent Lamothe and the First Lady of the Republic, Mrs. Sofia Martelly, representing the President of the Republic, Joseph Michel Martelly SEM, officially launched this Sunday, May 27, on the occasion of Mother's Day, the "Ti Manman Cheri" at the Joint Union School of the Apostles, in Cite Soleil, in the presence of members of the Council of Ministers and representatives of other countries.
http://lanaciondominicana.com/ver_noticia.php?id_noticia=35042&sesion_periodico=14
Agencia de Noticias Xinhua
Haitian Government launches program against extreme poverty
Haiti's government launched a program against extreme poverty with an initial fund of $ 13 million for the first year, through which seeks to ensure the education of poor children and ease the financial burden of families living in vulnerable areas, reported the Haitian Presidency. Prime Minister Laurent Lamothe and first lady of the Republic, Sophia Martelly, started the "You manman cheri" in Creole ("Dear mom" in Spanish) on Sunday on the occasion of Mother's Day, at a special event held in a school in Cite Soleil, one of the poorest in Port-au-Prince.
http://spanish.peopledaily.com.cn/31617/7830354.html
Z101 Digital
Haitian Government provides assistance to 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty
Haiti 's government launched a program of social protection to help cope with 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty throughout the country, reported the Office of Communication of the Presidency. They consist of the "Ti manman cherie" ("Mother dear"), which will allow mothers with one, two or three children each month receive 400 to 800 gourdes (9.5 to 19 U.S. dollars) to meet basic needs.
http://www.z101digital.com/app/article.aspx?id=66880
La Informacion
Haitian Government provides assistance to 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty
Haiti's government launched a program of social protection to help cope with 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty throughout the country, reported the Office of Communication of the Presidency.They consist of the "Ti manman cherie" ("Mother dear"), which will allow mothers with one, two or three children each month receive 400 to 800 gourdes (9.5 to 19 U.S. dollars) to meet basic needs.
http://noticias.lainformacion.com/p...en-en-pobreza-extrema_RZuveR1lZ0tVQLOWxbHtU2/
Diario Libre
Haitian Government provides assistance to 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty
Haiti's government launched a program of social protection to help cope with 100,000 mothers living in extreme poverty throughout the country, reported the Office of Communication of the Presidency.They consist of the "Ti manman cherie" ("Mother dear"), which will allow mothers with one, two or three children each month receive 400 to 800 gourdes (9.5 to 19 U.S. dollars) to meet basic needs.
http://www.diariolibre.com/noticias...100-000-madres-que-viven-pobreza-extrema.html