'Pain and Sex' posits that implanters (ancient psychiatrists) invented sex, invented the 2nd dynamic, not that they corrupted or attacked it.
No, that HCOB talks about the
wavelength called 'sex'. The word 'dynamic' is not even mentioned.
The "Urge No 2" = Wanting to have a family and a sexy mate, is not denied in this HCOB, quite the opposite: LRH states "To compound their felony ... [the psychs] tell you it's the body doing it." Since we know that bodies (e.g. animals) DO have sex and DO have pain that statement merely means that bodies do not create this
artificial 'sex wavelength' or
artificial 'pain wavelength'. That statement explains why thetan'ed bodies have so much more sex than animals and why animals don't torture other animals for fun and are not into BDSM games: Because only thetans produce these additional artificial wavelengths, which Hubbard calls 'sex' and 'pain'.
However it doesn't explain why anger is a "natural" wavelength to a thetan, while sex isn't. Maybe because pain and sex are not on the tone scale? Or because sex or pain can be combined with any other tone?
Please also remember how it was maybe LRH who did the research for this HCOB:
http://forum.exscn.net/showthread.php?t=10944
'Did Marty Rathbun initiate a new wave of "farming" of the recently (naive) "out"? Is the Freezone joining in the harvest? It's possible to diplomatically assist others to leave the "Church" without exploiting their naivete. What Ralph wrote is fine - but let's not be Goobers.
I also think that Ralph's post is OK, but the whole "Black Scientology" could be resolved easily by what we all know: Constant exposure (yes, real Scientology news with real statistics and real investigative interviews) and constant competition (just like you buy where it's cheaper and/or better). Then 99% of the madness would go away.
The abuses derive from the subject - the doctrine - of Scientology. If the subject is to be reformed, then that would need to be confronted.
Exactly, it's LRH's own bad apples that make the whole Church rot from within. There are bigger companies than the Church and they don't use Sea Org, Ethics or Scn Admin. It's not Miscavige's fault that there is the RPF.