Voltaire's Child
Fool on the Hill
Hey, I'll be the first to admit just about all (or maybe all) policies and a lot of "tech" stuff in CofS have ulterior motives, are two edged swords, are used for and more often against members. So that's a given. No disagreement there.
But, here's the thing. I think there were days when Hubbard was mellower and nicer. I think he had so many mixed motives he couldn't keep 'em all straight. I do not believe he only cared about the power and money but he cared so much about those things that this became what he was best known for and it's probably why he ended up as he did. But, all the same, I give credit where it's due. (I also have a critic friend who once called up a local org and explained that while she couldn't stand them, she thought it was great that they had this Toys for Tots drive. I like the cut of her jib.)
So one thing I've seen a couple people- including those are quite scathing whenever anyone dares to even try using one single gawdamn piece of Scn after leaving CofS because they're just trying to figure out wtf they should do - inveigh against is/are "good roads good weather".
But I think this is one of the few times where Hubbard and the organization actually got it right. Unlike some, I don't consider it to be dishonest or lying. I'm a businesswoman. I see people use it all the time at work. I can't tell you how many conversations I've had or seen where the weather or a new pet or home improvement or a movie is the focus. Or when people say "oh, fine" when asked how they are. It's a great way to communicate with others and maybe even to defray a rather tense situation. That doesn't mean that if one's ironing out a problem one really needs to address with a friend or family member that you just stick to: "oh, I saw Bridesmaids. It was really cute." No.
But there are times when good roads/good weather is a great idea.
One of the few PTS/SP PLs I actually liked (not that they actually abide by it. This IS the group that has many enforced disconnections, blackmail and coercion) is one where Hubbard gives an example of an enthusiastic and tactless newbie Scn'ist saying "I'm trying to confront your horrible bank" then is all amazed when his family doesn't like Scn. He recommends good roads good weather. Well, that makes sense. It's like the adage about discussing religion and politics.
I've also noticed that some of those who disagree with good roads/good weather the most are people who do not like being stood up to or argued with when stuff starts getting all personalized. Consider this: had things been kept good roads/good weather with them, then, well, a certain person maybe wouldn't have the reputation she has with them and with a few (clueless) lurkers, right?
A stopped clock is right twice a day. Sometimes Hubbard hit the nail on the head. That doesn't invalidate our many correct observations about overboarding, children in chain lockers, pushing people into believing they were implanted by Xenu, disconnection, RPF, high prices, Idle Orgs, etc.
But, here's the thing. I think there were days when Hubbard was mellower and nicer. I think he had so many mixed motives he couldn't keep 'em all straight. I do not believe he only cared about the power and money but he cared so much about those things that this became what he was best known for and it's probably why he ended up as he did. But, all the same, I give credit where it's due. (I also have a critic friend who once called up a local org and explained that while she couldn't stand them, she thought it was great that they had this Toys for Tots drive. I like the cut of her jib.)
So one thing I've seen a couple people- including those are quite scathing whenever anyone dares to even try using one single gawdamn piece of Scn after leaving CofS because they're just trying to figure out wtf they should do - inveigh against is/are "good roads good weather".
But I think this is one of the few times where Hubbard and the organization actually got it right. Unlike some, I don't consider it to be dishonest or lying. I'm a businesswoman. I see people use it all the time at work. I can't tell you how many conversations I've had or seen where the weather or a new pet or home improvement or a movie is the focus. Or when people say "oh, fine" when asked how they are. It's a great way to communicate with others and maybe even to defray a rather tense situation. That doesn't mean that if one's ironing out a problem one really needs to address with a friend or family member that you just stick to: "oh, I saw Bridesmaids. It was really cute." No.
But there are times when good roads/good weather is a great idea.
One of the few PTS/SP PLs I actually liked (not that they actually abide by it. This IS the group that has many enforced disconnections, blackmail and coercion) is one where Hubbard gives an example of an enthusiastic and tactless newbie Scn'ist saying "I'm trying to confront your horrible bank" then is all amazed when his family doesn't like Scn. He recommends good roads good weather. Well, that makes sense. It's like the adage about discussing religion and politics.
I've also noticed that some of those who disagree with good roads/good weather the most are people who do not like being stood up to or argued with when stuff starts getting all personalized. Consider this: had things been kept good roads/good weather with them, then, well, a certain person maybe wouldn't have the reputation she has with them and with a few (clueless) lurkers, right?
A stopped clock is right twice a day. Sometimes Hubbard hit the nail on the head. That doesn't invalidate our many correct observations about overboarding, children in chain lockers, pushing people into believing they were implanted by Xenu, disconnection, RPF, high prices, Idle Orgs, etc.