What's new

Marty Rathbun

Voltaire's Child

Fool on the Hill
Lol.

Yeah ... I have to admit I kind of love that about Terill P too, I think we may have turned into one if those 'crazy' families here!

Earl Grey anyone?

:giggle:

In the past, I've said that the workplace and relationship with coworkers is almost like an arranged marriage. Interesting relationships and interplay are established, etc.

Surely this is quite true of discussion forums. Your post was lighthearted but I'll get serious for a minute, if that's ok. On this forum, we've rallied to each other's aid with real concrete assistance- money, labor and advice and moral support. On other forums, I've met friends (from alt.religion.scientology and OCMB) and had them in my home, met them IRL in other places and love them as much as anyone I met anywhere else and made friends with.

Ok, end of seriousness. We're family and some of us (probably me, for one) are like one's eccentric Aunt Gertrude whom everyone cares about but makes allowances for her wackiness...
 

Voltaire's Child

Fool on the Hill
Was great meeting you also Geir. :)

I'm all in favour of meeting face to face, being somewhat sociable.
As well as attending protests regularly with anon, I've met and had good times with quite a few critics, notably Karen Spaink, Zenon Parnousis, and Mick Wenlock to name a few. We may not share views on the subject of scientology, but we share the wish to end abuses connected with COS.

I've met Terril. He's an absolute sweetie. I would also love to meet Geir.
 

Axiom142

Gold Meritorious Patron
Hey Ax!

Thanks for the detailed and reasoned response! Some clarifications:

SPIRITUAL LEADER: He may not have officially posted himself as such, but the way he stands in front of the light source (hubbard/scn) causes the shadows he casts. So, it is pretty safe to conclude that it's not an accident/coincidence that people regard him as such. (By way of example, I noticed that nobody is emailing me with praise about leading the new on-source Independent Bridge. :) )

Hey HH!

I agree that there seems to be a growing number of Scientologists who view him as a leader and so I guess this makes him a de facto leader. I suppose that people naturally want a leader to rally round in times of crises. I think that Marty sees himself more as a ‘target’, absorbing much of the wrath of the CoS and deflecting attention away from others so that they can do their work unmolested.

MAKING UP THE DAMAGE: Whatever he does is fine with me. I don't ask, require or expect him to make up any damage. Only be honest now. The concept of atonement for sins is a religious belief that I do not subscribe to. That is a control mechanism that I despise and would never want run on me (so I left Scn) and which I would never try to impose on another person. But, I would expect them to act honestly & transparently now--or I would not trust them. That is my only point.

Absolutely! Honesty is something that I want to see from those who want to be forgiven. People will more readily respect someone who has the guts to stand up and admit that they were wrong and be honest about what they did. And they will probably feel a lot better about themselves as well.



What's the big secret? What would prevent any rational man of good will from spilling what he knows? That's the problem---it has become convoluted into much speculation, meaning that Rathbun continues to spin webs of intrigue and confusion for others. What would happen if the world was simple? Rathbun would simply speak or write what he knows to put an end to the insanity created by Hubbard, CoS, DM and himself. …

I wish the world was simple too. But let’s not forget that the CoS has been playing their games of deceit, lies and manipulation for a long time. They have colossal financial reserves and are all too willing to use it in any way they can to achieve their aims. I fully expect to see some results in the not too distant future.

But we will still have plenty of other irons in the fire. :yes:



Wish I had started thinking with such rationality and morality a long, long time ago.

Me too HH, me too.

Axiom142
 

Zinjifar

Silver Meritorious Sponsor
That's not flying!

It's bouncing with style.

Ax

Well, it's at least as OT as anything I've seen from an OT :)

And, yes, they're another stupid cult, but, they're smarter than Scn in that they only really harass their own staff and their version of taking over the world only requires them to get 1% TMers; not actually *take it fucking Over*.

But, yeah, they can be almost as bizarre as Scn in the secret dogma, they're money grubbing (but, still, cheaper than Scn) and in the inner circles are also abusive. Not quite Sea Org abusive, but, unpleasant.

Zinj
 

Voltaire's Child

Fool on the Hill
"OT abilities" are the same things as psychic abilities, saintly manifestations, divine powers, shamanistic powers, magical powers. Scn does not have a monopoly on attempting to achieve or obtain such. It's just trying to do what people have been aware of- and have been sporadically achieving- for millennia.
 

Terril park

Sponsor
Terril,

I know what you mean about sharing the wish and other opinions not being shared. It boils down to respect and caring and I think you have shown that you are capable of these with others who believe differently than you.
I, myself, am working on this because I like alot of the people who don't agree with me on what I believe Scientology to be and I don't want to subjegate my integrity juest because we see differently. What brings us together is, as you say "the wish to end abuses connected with COS."

Never the less, it's important to recognize what ones intent really is and how responsible one is for their past acts that hurt others. I don't trust Marty because he attacks anyone who does not agree with him on the subjects of Scientology and LRH. What he said and did to Nancy Many, who worked with LRH, is unconscionable. He essentially called her a liar!

With that in mind, I would like to know what Marty said concerning his justifications about his attacks on David Mayo, the AAC and the Free Zone and how you managed to reconcile your affinity for him on this.

I would also like to know how did you reconcile the fact that Marty still thinks the Free Zone are a bunch of squirrels yet what he's doing is not 'squirrel'

Just curious.

Mary McConnell

I'm not aware of attacks on Nancy Many. Can you give me a link?

I'm not fully aware of Marty's attacks on those who disagree with SCN and LRH. Did see his left wing right wing thing. Thought it somewhat irrelevant
and not interesting to me. Again I'd like a link to attacks as I havn't read all his blog.

First point, Marty and myself support the tech, and I'd say the reason is on the order of revelatory miracles. Marty went exterior on a comm course I think he said. Among other things for me I controlled electrons. Don't ask, will all be told another day.

Marty mailed me and asked if I could recomend auditors prior to his blog and
after initial post on ESMB. Jim logan is on FZ forums and is a very theta guy.
We'd had a fair bit of comm. I think you know that Jim had real bad problems with Marty in COS. So I asked Jim is Marty to be trusted. Got very solid
re -assurences. So connected him to some highly qualified auditors. Good
results and referrals from Marty so far .

So Marty, Jim and I are very pro tech. So I'm disposed to be receptive to him.

He then does his thing with the SP times. The most effective attack on DM, and by implication the Church ever. Starts his blog which is pro tech.

I was critical of his euology re Earl Cooley.

Any way we meet. Really liked the guy and he is someone I'd like as a friend.

Marty's efforts have resulted in getting people out of the Church that I havn't been able to reach. Already connected people up to FZ techies.

It seems Marty has spent most of his time in SO dealing with attacks on COS.

Re the attack on Mayo he says that he has a different viewpoint now.
Not clarified much, like 3 hours in a pub with two conversations fugally intertwining? Says Mayo was a far better C/S int than Mithof.

Marty is not that happy with Mayo in that he took the money and ran so's to speak. And now is silent.

The legal case went on for 10 years, and Sarge Gerbode funded it. Was Sarge who said no more and ended it. Shame. Dunno if Marty knows that. Marty's words were that cos " Had its tits in a wringer" re that case. Should have gone on longer.

Marty made some sort of an apology to me re comments re Mayo, and it probably referred to a post of mine that he didn't allow on his blog. No big deal and resolved.

How do you know that Marty considers the FZ a bunch of squirrels? Please give a link.

He definitely considered me one. I've probably changed his mind there, but
dunno really. We are currently in good communication, which may be limited.

He thought I was " squirrelly" because I espoused Captain Bill Robertson's
" Sector 9" materials. Not only have I never posted about them, I've never even read them.

My guess is he got this idea from Veda.

So. I and Marty are pro tech.

I can't actually remember any time I made a very wrong judgement about a person.

Marty is agressive in the positive sense. He also shoots from the hip. He is though willing to change his viewpoint.

Hopefully Ax will give his viewpoint on all this.
 

Terril park

Sponsor
There are at least a half dozen variations of the, "I don't believe in the Xenu story" response, and these have been used ever since "Xenu" and the contents of the "OT 3" materials have been an issue.

Please tell. I only know two and a half. I posted here I don't believe it, but got gains from the level, COS PR deny its existence, and that probably soon to be RPFed PR in New Zealand vaguely acked it.

Please list the others.
 

AnonyMary

Formerly Fooled - Finally Free
I'm not aware of attacks on Nancy Many. Can you give me a link?
http://markrathbun.wordpress.com/what-we-do/
QUOTE:

Here is one exchange regarding Nancy:

Amy // December 4, 2009 at 5:12 pm | Reply

Marty,

Have you read Nancy Many’s book? She was an aid to LRH himself. She talks about being assigned to the RPF when she was 5 months pregnant and being locked in the garage at the Ft. Harrison Hotel during the pregnancy. This was ordered by Hubbard. Do these shocking revelations about LRH’s cruelty influence your opinion of him? So far you have only been critical of DM. It is important to highlight the evil of LRH as well.


martyrathbun09 // December 4, 2009 at 5:20 pm | Reply

Amy,
I write the truth according to my observations. If Nancy Many thinks LRH wanted her locked up at five months pregnant, Nancy Many has apparently communicated that to the world through her book. Nancy Many’s credibility took a deep dive south with me recently when she accused me of all manner of act and intention based on NO FACT. So, unfortunately I suppose for you, her account of LRH is taken by me with a grain of salt.

Amy // December 4, 2009 at 5:36 pm | Reply

That is really too bad Marty. However, your mindset of attacking the credibility of anyone who criticizes LRH or Scientology is right in line with LRH teachings and Scientology policy so I guess I am not surprised. I hope in the future when you have been out longer you will be able to acknowledge some of the nefarious acts of LRH as being true.


martyrathbun09 // December 4, 2009 at 6:44 pm | Reply

Amy,
In two short comments you’ve destroyed your own credibility, not with me but with every regular on this blog. You speak in generalities – “anyone who criticizes LRH or Scientology”. I never uttered a single hint of what you alleged I said.
-----------------------------------------------

I'm not fully aware of Marty's attacks on those who disagree with SCN and LRH. Did see his left wing right wing thing. Thought it somewhat irrelevant
and not interesting to me. Again I'd like a link to attacks as I havn't read all his blog.


Anyone who does not agree with his viewpoints, he calls them haters.

http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&q=site:markrathbun.wordpress.com+haters&btnG=Search&aq=f&oq=&aqi=

As far as the rest of the things you want links to, you need to give me a few days to research his exact comments.
 

Veda

Sponsor
How do you know that Marty considers the FZ a bunch of squirrels? Please give a link.

He definitely considered me one. I've probably changed his mind there

You're not a "squirrel"?

He thought I was " squirrelly" because I espoused Captain Bill Robertson's
" Sector 9" materials. Not only have I never posted about them, I've never even read them.

My guess is he got this idea from Veda.

So. I and Marty are pro tech.

I can't actually remember any time I made a very wrong judgement about a person.

You promote and recommend Captain Bill's Ron's Orgs, but have not read the "Sector 9" materials. That's hard to believe.

Why would you not take a little time and read something that directly relates to something that you're recommending to others?

Or is it the much used, "I dunno" defense?

What's that? Oh, you "can't remember" if you "dunno" or not.

Fine.
 

I told you I was trouble

Suspended animation
In the past, I've said that the workplace and relationship with coworkers is almost like an arranged marriage. Interesting relationships and interplay are established, etc.

Surely this is quite true of discussion forums. Your post was lighthearted but I'll get serious for a minute, if that's ok. On this forum, we've rallied to each other's aid with real concrete assistance- money, labor and advice and moral support. On other forums, I've met friends (from alt.religion.scientology and OCMB) and had them in my home, met them IRL in other places and love them as much as anyone I met anywhere else and made friends with.

Ok, end of seriousness. We're family and some of us (probably me, for one) are like one's eccentric Aunt Gertrude whom everyone cares about but makes allowances for her wackiness...

:giggle:

True ...
 

Veda

Sponsor
Please tell. I only know two and a half. I posted here I don't believe it, but got gains from the level, COS PR deny its existence, and that probably soon to be RPFed PR in New Zealand vaguely acked it.

Please list the others.

This area has been covered and covered and covered. Look into it on your own time if you wish.
 
Top