...
The first 20 minutes of that interview (while Marty was live on the air) was the quintessential defining moment of the movement known as Independent Scientology.
In wog terms, Marty and the Indies "jumped the shark" and they are forever doomed. There is no recovery from that devastating moment in time where any sane and rational being listening to Ratbun knows without any doubt or reservation that Indie Scientology is the same outrageous lying fraud that CoS is.
Identical. C=C=C. Cult equals Cult equals Cult.
Marty did not realize it, but he singlehandedly dropped an
H-bomb into the Indie Volcano and blew it up real good. What was the H-Bomb? The Hubbard bomb, the very same blatant lying that Mr.
H-Bomb himself used,
Hubbard. Hubbard bombed because he told so many lies that he was forced to go into hiding in a Bluebird motorhome. Honest people don't have to hide. (Note to Scientologists and Indie Scientologists: Did you ever once know any person in your life that was hiding from authorities? Why would an OT have to hide if they are OT?)
Let's take a sampling of Marty's Indie-shattering technology:
QUESTION: Do you believe in (75 million years ago Xenu the galactic emporer sent people to Teegeack and blew them up in volcanoes to solve overpopulation?)
RATHBUN: I don't believe anything.
QUESTION: Do you believe (in the story of Xenu and space aliens?)
RATHBUN: They're analogies, they're stories.
QUESTION: Are the spirits of the aliens in me?
RATHBUN: No
QUESTION: Do you believe (that 75 million years ago Xenu sent beings to earth that are now trapped in our bodies?)
RATHBUN: (You are) taking things too literally. I don't believe it. I don't believe anything. It's a collateral story.
QUESTION: If I no longer believe in the Divinity of Christ, am I a Christian?
RATHBUN: Yes.
QUESTION: Are there thetans in my body?
RATHBUN: No.
If Miscavige was really smart, he would call a mandatory "briefing" of all Scientologists who are OT III or above and bring them into a bonded, top-secret meeting at which he would simply play the 20 minutes of the Rathbun radio interview. That would be the ultimate dead agent handling of all time in the history of the Church of Scientology.
OT's listening to that short interview would hear in Marty's own words the denial of the holiest Hubbard/Scientology scripture. It would be definitive proof that Marty was an SP SQUIRREL who was attempting to destroy mankind's only hope.
Denial of OT III and Body Thetans? No Scientologist would ever, ever, ever have a single doubt or reservation about who/what the "Indie Movement" was.
It would be a brilliant move in the cult vs cult battle. Twenty minutes, that's all it would take and Marty would be "quietly disposed of without sorrow".
Even more fascinating is this question...
HOW MUCH COGNITIVE DISSONANCE WOULD IT TAKE FOR AN INDIE SCIENTOLOGIST TO HEAR THAT INTERVIEW AND NOT KNOW THAT MARTY RATHBUN IS PUBLICLY LYING ABOUT THEIR RELIGION AND CORE BELIEFS...AND STILL REMAIN A "LOYAL OFFICER" IN THE INDIE CULT?
A better question is this:
HOW MANY LIES DOES IT TAKE FOR A SCIENTOLOGIST TO COGNITE THAT THEY ARE BEING LIED TO?
I understand what you are saying Helly, and you raise an interesting point about how COS could spin this...if they could speak openly about OT three to OT's, which they can't...Scientologists lie constantly to maintain the system...it's a normal state of being for them. They lie to themselves to stay in, and they lie to others to KSW, and they lie to "handle" outside criticism or bad publicity, whether from media or their friends and family. Ron modeled it for them and they follow in his footsteps. Who are the elite of Scientology, the best of the best with FULL privileges, who freely spend the Cult money and steer the ship of the Cult Culture? It's not the public, it's not the staff, it's not even most of the lowly Sea Org members, slaving away in hot kitchens, or scraping paint and pulling weeds, filing and writing letters and emails to sell more books, it's those few who are in RTC which runs OSA and everything else. First Ron and his hand-picked minions, and now Miscavige and his hand-picked minions. Making up and selling believable lies is how they have survived all this time. Read Robert Vaughn Young"s excellent article on about this at:
http://www.xenu.net/archive/go/quill.htm
To my way of thinking, in this radio interview, Marty was telling an "acceptable" truth... for public consumption.

Nothing new about doing that, surely!
I would like to think that he actually means it, as it would mean that he IS more in touch with our commonly accepted reality base than his having served at Int base for so long would indicate...I do see signs that he has been actually waking up even more from the Scientology dream of life and reality, as hopefully ALL former Cult members (COS members) will eventually do.
I think he
does believe that one can be "culturally" a Scientologist and not take literally the Zenu story, just as one can "culturally" be a Christian and not take literally most of the stories in the Bible. I think a lot of upper-level Executives can hold this consideration. I think the Space Opera elements are not what attracts them to continuing to do Scientology, but are rather incidental to their doing Scientology.
I understand why he did the interview and I think he is trying to make Ron's "Space Opera" (what Ron called it HIMSELF) dogma into an acceptable truth for the general public...I myself have personally heard Scientologists say (about the Zenu origin myth explaining why we are here on earth) that it's no more or less believable than the idea of a virgin giving birth to the son of God or there being a talking snake in the garden of Eden).
Holding a (any) consideration that will serve a greater purpose is something he was taught and is well-practiced at doing. (That IS being pan-determined...the ability to hold any consideration and not only be o.k. with it, but to make things go right via using it with others to serve your purpose or achieve your goal...) I think it is, for him, a way to play a winning game.
Would it alarm anybody to hear that this is the consideration that many if not most Int Base and other upper level Scientology Executives hold about the Zenu creation myth? Remember, according to this Space Opera consideration, we ourselves as Thetans were accorded this same "processing and implantation", etc, as the BT's underwent, only we were TIGERS enough as Thetans to stand up under it and able enough to get our acts together to claim or collect our own G.E. bodies to run to enable us to live out lifetime after lifetime, until we finally free all the trapped Thetans on this planet (and in this quadrant?) that are too weak, confused or degraded to know or free themselves...poor things, and we are able enough ourselves to no longer "need" a Genetic Entity body to operate (really an OT).
According to this Space Opera dogma, it puts us in the starring role as the superiorly able and aware saviors of mankind, and the only ones on the planet who REALLY know what is going on...which pushes big buttons for Sea Org members in general and Int Base and upper level Executives specifically...they pride themselves on being TIGERS, the most able beings on the planet, in spite of all evidence to the contrary that they are just as humbly human as all the rest of us, with flaws, failings and vulnerabilities in reality (no such thing as a real OT, except
as a consideration) as any other person.
I think this is how some upper-level Scientologists can tolerate that particular bit of implanted insanity, the wall of "fire" dogma: (Remember, the vase majority of people who get into Scientology blow before dealing with this or get "stalled" somewhere lower on the Bridge.) They (publicly or privately) consider it to be an origin myth on a par with the garden of Eden story, for the greater good of the movement, if they are Sea Org or staff, and so that they themselves will be allowed to continue to do processes and "progress" up through the levels up the bridge, if they are public. It's not important to them or their "progress" in the Cult Organization that they REALLY believe it to be factual, if they can accept it as mythic and get self-perceived benefits from doing the processing (which some say they do).
Just because I love his efforts to make amends, here is a portion of Robert Vaughn Young's work, which illustrates my point about lying as a way of life for Scientologist Executives:
How To Fool The Press: A study in misinformation
by Robert Vaughn Young
"In nearly 20 years of handling the media for Scientology and Hubbard, I dealt with a lot of journalists. One of the most challenging occurred in 1980, when the Riverside Press-Enterprise broke a story by Dick Lyneis that Hubbard was secretly ensconced at a nearby deserted resort called Gilman Hot Springs.
Since the FBI raid on Scientology offices in 1977, Hubbard had been the target of an increasing number of process servers and government investigators. His location had become one of Scientology's best-kept secrets. When necessary, Hubbard could move and he did.
But the headquarters of Scientology International in Gilman Hot Springs could not move so easily. Although Hubbard claimed not to be running the Church of Scientology, in fact he did. Here was the seat of the Hubbard Holy Empire, 90 minutes east of Los Angeles. Hubbard was not eager for attorneys, the media, or the Internal Revenue Service to know this.
I was sent in to handle the situation.
As in Clearwater, Florida, Scientology had covertly bought the Gilman Hot Springs property and secretly moved in. The phone book listed it as the "Scottish Highland Quietude Club." Few driving by were interested in the few people who occasionally walked between the buildings.
By the time I arrived, Hubbard had disappeared. Most of the staff he had deserted were terrified because the security he had demanded had been blown. They knew his temper and they feared his wrath.
I toured the property and found a small film-making area and an audio tape production unit, called Golden Era, which was supposed to supply materials to the Church of Scientology. Both had been shut down by Hubbard, but I saw my solution. It was, as he called it, "an acceptable truth." I obtained L.A.'s approval for my plan.
Through that night and into the morning, the facility was converted. I had the paper covering all the windows taken off. Everything was cleaned. Equipment and desks were rearranged to hide certain tasks and to create others. Tapes, films, scripts, and costumes were dragged out and made obvious. Many international management staff were sent off the base to reduce the number of personnel.
The next day, the "Scottish Highland Quietude Club" had become Golden Era Studios. A media tour went without a hitch. The tape-production area wasn't cranking yet, but I did get people busy making costumes and booklets or doing artwork. We found a makeshift studio that "just happened" to be working when the tour came through. Asked about "international management," I said yes, they did manage distribution of films and tapes, which did go to churches worldwide. No one noticed I had avoided the question and diverted attention to the film and tape production.
The news that night was perfect. The Riverside Press-Enterprise story had been countered. Gilman was no longer considered the headquarters of Scientology. It was just a bustling film and tape facility that supplied the Church of Scientology.
When the flap died down, international management quietly moved back in. Since then Golden ERA Productions has expanded considerably. There are even guided public tours and PR glitz, including an occasional VIP or Scientology celebrity tour of the tape and film facilities. No one asks about the other function we were able to quietly reinstall after the flap was handled., or the other management organizations that were quietly added.
But they're there, just up the hill from the sound stage, not too far from the spa where the hot springs no longer flow."