Maria Cuervo
Gold Meritorious Patron
Re: The old days - Aboard the Apollo - 1973
I really appreciate the explanation and it is an area I know nothing much of so I learned things I need to know! And love the chicken and egg explanation! Brilliant! Was not Godel also Einstein's close chum?
And yes perhaps there are others as smart as he was but who lacked the drive and effort and therefore did not achieve what he could....
Hi Maria, I'm very happy that you took my critique of your post in the constructive manner in which I intended it. Also, I am happy that you agreed with some of the examples which I gave. I do thank you very much for the clarification you present above as to why you were speaking and the fact that you were speaking to over-ego both inside and outside of CoS.
Now, onto the question you directly asked me and the question you compared it to, the chicken and the egg problem, I am going to attempt answers to both questions. First, let me state that I believe that I believe I know the answer to the question of which came first, the chicken or the egg? Actually, the answer I have is quite simple and it is based totally on empirical evidence.
Consider a similar question, what came first the automobile or the automobile factory? If you consider that question on a par with the chicken and the egg question, the answer is immediately apparent!! I think the year was 1889 and the place was in Germany and someone named Gottfried Daimler built the first gasoline powered automobile that was able to run, be steered and be stopped. Note that no automobile factory had yet been constructed. True, the car had to be built someplace, undoubtedly in Daimler's garage. Various parts had to either be purchased from other sources and produced by Daimler as well. For example, wheels, the suspension system, the car body and possible the brakes might have been purchased from a horse drawn carriage maker and brought to Daimler's garage. Some might even say that the garage, in this case, was the first automobile factory and therefore the factory came first.
I would maintain strongly that the automobile came first. There is no doubt about it. The garage was a garage. All Daimler needed were various parts, various tools, and a space in which to do his assembly. This same sequence applies for probably every product dreamed up by mankind. There were books or even scrolls before the first book factory, a prototype tank had to exist before any tank factory could be built, etc., etc.
In fact, the product always has to exist first because the factory must be designed around the product which is going to be built there. How could someone build an automobile factory until at least one successful prototype automobile had become operational? Therefore, I say the a living chicken had to exist before the first egg was hatched!
Your second question is much harder to answer. "Do you think that this ability to push further came from natural endowment, e.g., a genius such as Einstein did it because he has more gifts or is effort on its own the main cause?" I have never contemplated the question before so let's take a look at it. Definitely Einstein had more gifts than others, there is absolutely no doubt about that but that doesn't do much to answer your question. Other scientists came close to beating Einstein in releasing his Special theory of Relativity, Ernst Mach, Lorenz and Fitzgerald come to mind. They were close as regards Einstein's special relativity. As to his General Theory of Relativity, no one else was close. Einstein got some help from his associates in the new field of quantum physics which was then being developed. Max Plank of Germany pioneered that field along with Heisenberg and others. Plank in particular became a close friend and valuable associate, the two played chamber music together. Plank stood up for Einstein against Hitler. Hitler became disgusted and left the conference, muttering about plank under his breath but Plank was too powerful a figure for Hitler to bring down.
Einstein built on the work of Isaac Newton. Newton had to do his work first, before an Einstein could along and build upon it some 200 years later. Newton built on the work of others as well but it was basically the one two punch of Newton, then Einstein plus the scientists who pioneered and developed quantum physics who led to the physics of today.
Of course, Einstein was encouraged to get involved in physics by his father. He genetic line spanned many generations but no one else in his family showed any particular gift in understanding physics.. One thing about Einstein, he was not inspired by working under some great professor of physics. He worked alone and he always thought outside the box. He venerated Sir Isaac Newton. Among his contemporaries he was close friends with Max Plank until Hitler took power and Einstein left to live in the USA.
So, Maria, it is just my opinion but I believe the answer to your question about Einstein is that Einstein as an individual had more gift than others and the driving force in his life was to use his gift to its full extent. He knew that he didn't know, he knew that he could know more than he did and he knew that even after making major breakthroughs, he still did not know all that much. True, he would not have been able to do what he did had not Newton and several others preceded him and had not his parents encouraged him and supported him but other than that, he was simply one man acting alone. He was driven to solve riddles of the Universe, and acting alone or sometimes with a team of scientists he went about his business, using his genius and his gifts to see deeper than others to their fullest extents.
That is all my opinion, maybe with that and $3.95 you could buy a cup of coffee at Starbucks.
Lakey
And yes perhaps there are others as smart as he was but who lacked the drive and effort and therefore did not achieve what he could....

L.A. was rockin in dem days. And Einstein attended when it was brand new.