George, you have got things mashed up horribly. yes I have had a lot of personal gain from doing Scientology the way I did it. And yes, many many people were messed up doing Scientology the way they did it. My way of doing it is in no way a "purified form". It's just the way I found I could get good results for me and others, and it is very much a work in progress.
Everybody certainly does have the freedom to choose. In no way am I lessening that right. Where/how do you imagine that I am?
I look at the way the guys here say they experienced Scientology and I look at Jason Beghe's description of what he experienced and I see clearly that that is not the Scientology I did. What he and many on this board have experienced is the bastardized remnant form of the subject the the CofS in its ignorance is promoting as the real thing. And mush of this bastardized form is what Hubbard himself promoted while in his senile dotage.
So I say Hey, that's not what Scientology is or was ever meant to be. That's not what it needs to be. It can be done differently.
Do you have a problem with me doing that?
If you were conned then for yuo ut certainly is a con game. And for anyone else too who reckons they were conned.
But I was not conned and so for me it is not a con game. When it turned into one in the early 1980s I got out of there.
Yes and Yes
So quite obviously he himself didn't know what a Clear was. Nor how to recognise one. Like I said earlier - it is undefinable.
Indeed.
So let me understand this all so far...
You acknowledge that Hubbard was a con artist.
You agree he defined the state of clear to include, among other things, perfect recall of events.
You acknowledge that the state of clear he proposed doesn't exist as, among other things, clears do not have perfect recall of events.
You do not have a definition of a clear.
The official people who are using the so called 'tech' are not doing it right.
The inventor of the so called 'tech' wasn't doing it right.
You admit that much of the tech is bad or doesn't work...
...and you are still committed to this idea?
This reminds me of when I bought my first used car.
The person who sold it to me said it was the best car ever and that I needed to conjure up magic fuel to run it, but the mileage would be
more than I could possibly imagine (which reminded me of some science fiction I like, and I guess that was what hooked me in) and that the car will drive with greater precision and faster and that it will damage the suspension less going over bumps. Wheel alignment would be automatic and the car would clear itself of rubbish.
I had real difficulty trying to conjure up magic fuel, and they charged me for a series of expensive courses.
When I tried to get my money back, they followed me home, harassed me at work and did other such things.
It later emerged that the guy who sold me the car (who is now dead), was a known con artist.
The organization has offices in France and all over the USA. Apparently, the organization has found guilty of fraud and individual members have been charged with fraud, extortion, burglary, assault, attempted murder and a list of the sorts of crimes organized criminal organizations are charged with from time to time.
The used car sales lot is now owned by a manic depressed dwarf with alcohol problems and asthma who still calls me trying to sell me courses. Apparently his terminal asbestosis has metastasized to his brain and his is losing his mind. Thankfully, he was stupid and uneducated, so it wasn't a big fall.
He is known to beat his staff on a regular basis during sales meetings. On occasion, during some of the sales meetings, rather than masturbating, he instead assaults his staff.
I have since thrown out the vehicle and the DVD sets, but I have kept some of the books on magic fuel, because some of it rings true to me. I fully acknowledge that there is no research to support this and that various government agencies have raided the organization and charged them with making fraudulent claims, but
what is true is what's true for me. I love that expression as it is the most succinct distillation of the essence of superstition itself.
I am still convinced that magic fuel is real. I can't define what it is, but while driving in another car I purchased, using regular fuel, I have the sense that my car works better because of the magic.
Does anyone have a problem with that?